Lesson One - It's Okay To Use Schoolish Materials!
 |
My girls in that first year. |
I think it is the most guilt producing quote ever published in the homeschool world. "Don't base your school after the public schools." There are entire articles and blogs and curriculum based on this thought. And, the thing is, most of us start out basing our homeschool on our own learning history. We may think we want different, but we still often start with what we know, how we were taught.
What was intended to set us free can actually add more pressure at times.
When I first began homeschooling several years ago, I had an idea in my head about how I would homeschool my child (we started with just one). I went to a bookstore that sold used homeschool materials and bought the first math program in my daughter's grade. I bought a spelling book and some workbooks. I picked up some library books. That was school to me. She was in the third grade. My idea of school was some workbooks and lots of reading. I read to her... a lot... and I think that was the best thing I could have done for her at the time.
 |
Two of my homeschoolers |
Immediately I stressed because she wasn't getting the math. Turned out it was too advanced, as many homeschool math programs are compared to public school. So, I bought a different book and off we went.
That first year, when I look back over my blog posts, I was so scared. I would read all this amazing stuff by other homeschoolers and think they had the answer. One of the first things I read, and then read and read and read was that making our homeschool into school at home was BAD! And, after seven years, I agree... and disagree.
 |
Notecard timeline |
We don't have a chalkboard. We don't have desks, except the computer desk. We don't raise our hands to ask a question. So, in essence, we aren't reproducing school at home. However, I took this to mean that we should not use school materials much if there was a better way. After a few months I really didn't care about what the schools were teaching, except in math, and if what I was teaching was lining up. However, I thought that by using "schoolish" type stuff, such as textbooks or workbooks. They were all dry and boring and will create children that can't think for themselves and will never get a quality education.
Yes, that is what many of those articles and posts said... and still say to this day.
Are they right? Well, sometimes... in some subjects. I would try the use "real" books for everything, especially history and science. I would spend a ton of money or would check out piles of library books. I would spend hours planning. And, it wasn't bad. My daughter and I enjoyed many of those books. However, often she would be sick of all the reading. She is a good reader, but even for her it was overload at times. I had a toddler, and felt like I was trying to have read aloud time in a tornado. My toddler wasn't much for nap time either, so that
plan usually didn't pan out well.
 |
Math Games |
In frustration, and because I couldn't tell how much my daughter was learning, I would order the workbooks. For awhile she would work on those. She was such a good reader that they were usually too easy... again, except for math. I didn't think about trying a harder level at the time. My daughter would do well with the workbooks... too well. Then I would read yet another article about how school materials like workbooks were so horrible and I needed to be using "real" books, and I would stress and worry and wonder if I was failing my child. I would pray for God to show me the right CURRICULUM. Surely, there was one curriculum that was perfect... and affordable. The answer had to be a curriculum, and since school materials were bad, it must be a curriculum company that used "real" books.
I didn't mention that, while we used the workbooks, I also had some of those "real" books scheduled. I also kept doing read aloud time when I could. I just assumed that I was cheating my child out of a quality education.
Then came the Charlotte Mason curriculum loaded with those magic "real" books. It was like Christmas morning when box day happened and all those wonderful books arrived. There is nothing like the smell of opening a box of brand new books. I LOVE BOOKS!! This was perfect! Now, my daughter and I would have all these adventures, learning along the way. And, there were days when it was fun. We both love books. I had all the scheduling planned out for me with a handy little guide. As long as nothing went wrong, we were great. But, nothing is perfect.

I got sick. My gallbladder started giving me attacks. I had this great curriculum, but the attacks from my gallbladder made me too sick to do the curriculum the way it was written. I didn't sleep well. Laura was still young and wasn't very independent in her work. I had a toddler that needed me. I was having to eat a nearly no-fat diet until my insurance kicked in and I could have the surgery. I was so tired and weak, and I was constantly sick with whatever cold or virus was going around. I had multiple upper-respitory infections. It is really tough to do read-alouds when you can't breath through your nose and you are coughing so much your chest feels like it is on fire. My program called for me reading at least two or three books a day to my daughter, and on many days I couldn't do it. My family helped when they could, but my husband was working and my older girls were in public school.
The following year my husband was laid off. We spent a few months on unemployment after the company he was working for went out of business. Then, when he did find a job, it was at a large pay cut. Affording the expensive Charlotte Mason curriculum was out. I was back to putting stuff together myself.
About a year later circumstances changed in our home a bit. One of my high schoolers came home to be homeschooled. She was under the guidance of a teacher that specialized in homeschooling in our area. The lady has a master's degree in education and had homeschooled for years and years. She placed my high school daughter in a worktext program. Since this lady was making the transcript, I didn't care what my daughter used. It was a Christian program, and I was so nervous about homeschooling my high schooler that I just followed along. I added some reading, but didn't mess too much with changing anything. My high school daughter used the program for two years, enjoyed most of it, and graduated. She is now about to graduate from college. I guess the workbook program didn't fail her.
 |
Workbook time |
I've since pulled another daughter out of public school and began homeschooling that toddler. That toddler is now in second grade. I have used such a mixed up bunch of stuff over the years. And, I can tell you, there is no magic curriculum. I still love books. I always will. I use them to supplement a couple of those horrible workbook/worktext programs. I use a couple computer programs for my high school students. I am not afraid to find a math game for my second grader. I still have the Charlotte Mason programs, and will probably use them in a year or two for history and science with my youngest. I think mixing things up a bit from time to time helps children learn more. I have bought so much stuff, including entire unit study materials that cover Kindergarten through High School. I loved the concept, but struggled to make it work for me.
Guess what, It is okay to use "school" materials. I use a lot of Christian materials, and some of them are used in Christian schools. That's okay. My children are learning. Education is about a lot of different things. The schoolish workbooks are only a part of our education. Books, documentaries, computer programs, occasional projects, field trips when possible... these are part of a quality education. The one-on-one that my children receive is better than anything they would get in public school.
I find it ironic that the way I thought homeschool should be when I first began, after seven years and trying all the different methods and many of the different curricula, is not much different from how I educate my children now. I have learned so much over the years, about how children learn, about what works for my family, and about how other people's opinions aren't gospel. Maybe their did their best work by building a giant eyeball under the table. I only liked occasional projects. One program had a poetry unit where every week she was painting a picture to go with the poem. That was awesome! But, it worked for her. I don't know if my younger daughter will enjoy it or not. The experience will be good for her. I love the memories of making cookies from a country we were studying or watching a movie about that time in history we had just read about. However, when everything had to be a "learning experience", the experiences lost their impact.

After seven years homeschooling, and four students (one graduated), I no longer live in fear that a textbook will ruin my child. Our home is not a local school. The stresses and problems in a classroom environment aren't here. A textbook can be supplemented. We can skip things if necessary. But, if I just want to make sure that school is getting done, without Mom having to be healthy every day, then I know that our workbooks are useful. I know I can switch out a workbook program one year for a unit study or some Charlotte Mason flair. And, the next year, go right back into a workbook program, maybe tweaking something else. I've relaxed in my approach, and have watched my children soar.